By Raymundo Larraín Nesbitt
Lawyer – abogado
16th of July 2021
Tax form 720, only mentioning it brings cold shivers to most taxpayers. It is single-handedly responsible for a mass exodus of thousands of expats since its inception and has acted as a firm deterrent of thousands more who refused to become tax residents in Spain to avoid it.
The disproportionate fines of this tax form had been challenged at Brussels and we were expecting a ruling on this matter last autumn, but I guess the emergence of the virus impacted on everything pushing it back.
The ECJ’s General Advocate, Mr. Henrik Saugmandsgaard, in a press release of yesterday concluded that Spain’s unfamous tax from 720 had implemented a system of disproportionate fines that go against the spirit of the Union.
Quoting the text: “M. Saugmandsgaard observe que ces amendes forfaitaires sont 15, 50 et 66 fois plus élevées que celles appliquées dans des situations internes.“ The fines are 15, 50, and 66 times higher than those applied in internal situations.
He continues: “Même en tenant compte de la marge d’appréciation dont disposent les États membres afin d’établir les sanctions appropriées, ces amendes sont tellement élevées qu’elles paraissent disproportionnées, sans qu’il soit nécessaire de faire ici la distinction entre les différentes catégories de biens.“ Even if Member states have the power to modulate the appropriate fines, these fines are disproportionate without even needing to go into the different types of assets.
The gist of his report is that, as we had cared to point out repeatedly over the years, the fines levied by the Spanish Tax Office are completely disproportionate by rapport to other cases; they simply jump off the scale for no apparent reason.
He concludes: “L’avocat général propose donc à la Cour de déclarer que l’Espagne a manqué aux obligations qui lui incombent de garantir la liberté consacrée à l’article 63 TFUE (capitaux) ainsi que la liberté correspondante prévue à l’accord sur l’EEE…“ The General Advocate proposes the ECJ to declare Spain in breach of the freedom of movement of capital enshrined in art. 63 of the TFEU. In other words, and in plain English, with this tax regulation Spain is breaching the core covenant of the foundational European treaty of Rome which sets out a series of freedoms as the guiding spirit of our Union.
What significance does his report hold?
None, because it’s just a non-binding report. The report has only a purpose of guidance, but it is ultimately non-binding and not enforceable in any way.
All, because in 80% of the cases the ECJ follows the meticulous criteria laid out by its General Advocate. This is the first step of two required to overrule these lopsided penalties imposed by Spain.
The ECJ’s ruling
In a few months’ time (likely by the fall of ‘21) the ECJ will give it’s final ruling on tax form 720. In line with what we were long expecting, it will declare the overblown fines as null and void.
Kudos to our EU Overlords on this, they are right on track to rein in the Spanish Tax Office’s fiscal voracity.
Spain is the fifth country in the whole OECD (38 countries) with the highest fiscal pressure. Notable exceptions within Spain are the autonomous regions of Andalusia and Madrid (because of devolved competencies on tax matters).
If anything, Spain needs to urgently lower its taxes to become more competitive, attract foreign investments, and foster commercial activity on a large scale. Spain’s taxes are far too high as they stand right now. Also, I may add on a personal note, its bloated public sector needs to be trimmed down significantly to more manageable levels in line with fellow EU Member states.
“L’art de l’imposition consiste à plumer l’oie pour obtenir le plus possible de plumes avec le moins possible de cris.” – Jean Baptiste Colbert.
French economist and Finance Minister under King Louis XIV.
Translated as: “The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing.”
At LNA we can assist you buying, selling or renting out your property in Spain. We have 18 years’ experience in conveyance & tax. We are also specialized in Immigration & Residency permits.
Larraín Nesbitt Abogados, small on fees, big on service.
Larraín Nesbitt Lawyers is a law firm specialized in taxation, inheritance, conveyancing, residency, and litigation. We will be very pleased to discuss your matter with you. You can contact us by e-mail at email@example.com, by telephone on (+34) 952 19 22 88, or by completing our contact form to book an appointment.
Please note the information provided in this blog post is of general interest only and is not to be construed or intended as substitute for professional legal advice. This article may be posted freely in websites or other social media so long as the author is duly credited. Plagiarizing, whether in whole or in part, this article without crediting the author may result in criminal prosecution. VOV.
2021 © Raymundo Larraín Nesbitt. All Rights Reserved.
Blog post first published on SPI: European Court of Justice’s lead council states Spanish Tax Form 720 fines are disproportionate